Hayl's Kitchen

  • All Recipes!
  • Subscribe
  • About
menu icon
go to homepage
  • All Recipes!
  • Subscribe
  • About
search icon
Homepage link
  • All Recipes!
  • Subscribe
  • About
×

GET THE BEST REcipes for free in your email!

Home » Recipes » Desserts

Protein Pumpkin Pie: 11g Protein, No Sugar, No Condensed Milk

by Haylee Jane Monteiro · Modified: Nov 9, 2026 · Published: Nov 21, 2023
This post may contain affiliate links.

Protein pumpkin pie with 10.6g of protein and 176 calories a slice, no condensed milk, no sugar in the filling, and a clean slice every time after an overnight chill. Traditional pumpkin pie runs about 4g of protein and twice the calories. This one hits your macros and still tastes like the real thing.

Jump to Recipe Jump to Video Print Recipe
Protein Pumpkin Pie is soft and creamy but healthy! Made using protein powder - no sugar or condensed milk - it’s perfect to celebrate Thanksgiving party with health goals in check.

If you are tracking through the holidays, pumpkin pie is usually the dish that knocks everything sideways. All that sweetened condensed milk and added sugar makes it hard to fit into a day without blowing your numbers. That is exactly the problem this recipe solves. The protein powder takes the place of the sweetener, the Greek yogurt keeps the filling creamy, and the whole thing bakes up soft and smooth with no compromise on flavor.

My husband kept asking me for this pie even after I had a chocolate one on the counter, and we are very much chocolate people. That should tell you something. If you want to keep your Thanksgiving table macro-friendly from start to finish, my high protein sweet potato casserole is worth making right alongside this one.

Update Oct 2025: I re-baked this after two years and rebuilt the crust and the instructions. The filling was already right, so I left it alone. Blind-baking the crust first was the change that mattered.
The variable I can't control is your protein powder. Brands don't sweeten the same, and the Quest vanilla whey-casein I use is sweet enough that the filling needs nothing extra. If yours is milder, taste the batter and add stevia or vanilla extract before it goes in the crust. Ingredients first, since the powder decides most of this.

Why You'll Love This Healthy Pumpkin Pie Recipe

  • 10.6 grams of protein and 175 calories in one roll, frosting included.
  • No condensed milk and no added sugar. The vanilla protein powder handles both the sweetness and the structure.
  • Soft and creamy filling that slices cleanly after chilling. No cracking, no rubbery texture.
  • One bowl for the filling. Whisk, pour, bake.
  • Pre-baked crust that stays crisp. The 2025 update made this non-negotiable.
  • Fits right on a Thanksgiving table without looking or tasting like a "healthy" version of anything.

Ingredients for High Protein Pumpkin Pie Recipe:

A short list, and each one is doing real work in the filling.

  • Frozen Ready-to-Bake Pie Crust: I use Pillsbury. Pre-baking it is not optional here; a raw crust under a wet filling turns soft and dense. See the gluten-free note below if you need an alternative.
    • Sub: A fresh or homemade pie crust. Be sure to blind-bake and cool first.
  • Pure pumpkin puree: Canned is better here. Libby's is my go-to. Homemade puree has more moisture variation, which makes the filling harder to set. And double-check the label: pumpkin pie filling already has sugar and spices added, which will throw off the whole recipe.
  • Vanilla Protein Powder; This is replacing both the sugar and the condensed milk to give you a low sugar recipe. I recommend Quest Nutrition vanilla since it is a whey-casein and bakes well. That blend is what keeps the filling soft instead of rubbery. My protein pumpkin bread uses the same logic for the same reason.
    • Sub: A plant-based vanilla protein like KOS works, but add a little stevia and an extra splash of vanilla extract since plant-based powders tend to run less sweet and more earthy.
    • Sub: Whey isolate could work (I haven't tested it out), but reduce the almond milk to about ⅓ to ½ cup. Isolate absorbs liquid faster and you will end up with a filling that is too runny if you keep the full amount.
  • Unsweetened Almond Milk - Thins the filling to the right consistency for pouring.
    • Sub: Use Regular Milk or any other non-dairy milk like unsweetened soy milk or coconut milk.
  • Nonfat Plain Greek Yogurt - Just 3 tablespoons, but it rounds out the filling and adds a little tang that keeps it from tasting flat. It also adds a small boost to the protein count.
    • Sub: Coconut yogurt will also work, or cottage cheese blended smooth
  • Eggs and Egg Whites - Structure and set. The whole eggs bring richness, the extra white keeps the protein up without adding fat. Whisk them in last and only until just combined.
  • Pumpkin Pie Spice and Cinnamon - The spice blend does most of the flavor work. Taste the filling before it goes in the crust and adjust from there.

Ingredient Swaps and Adaptations

Gluten Free Skip the frozen Pillsbury crust and use an oat flour crust, or press a simple crust made from crushed almonds and a small amount of butter substitute into the pie dish. Either way, blind-bake it and let it cool fully before adding the filling.

Dairy Free Coconut yogurt in place of the Greek yogurt, plant-based vanilla protein for the powder, and any unsweetened non-dairy milk. The filling will be slightly less tangy but still creamy.

Vegan Flax eggs in place of the whole eggs and egg white (1 tablespoon flaxseed meal plus 3 tablespoons water per egg, rested 5 minutes). The filling will take longer to set and will be a little denser. Chill overnight without skipping it. Also use the dairy free swaps listed about.

Protein Pumpkin Pie is soft and creamy but healthy! Made using protein powder - no sugar or condensed milk - it’s perfect to celebrate Thanksgiving party with health goals in check.

How to make Sugar Free Protein Pumpkin Pie

The filling comes together in one bowl. The only split in the process is baking the crust separately first, and that is what makes the bottom stay crisp.

The Pie Crust:

  1. Preheat to 450°F and roll your pie crust into the pie dish and press it firmly against the sides and bottom.
  2. Blind Bake for 12-15 minutes, or until the edges begin to turn a light golden brown. Keep an eye on it toward the end.
  3. Cool completely. This usually takes about 25 minutes. Do not skip this step! Pouring warm filling into a warm crust traps steam and softens everything. You want a cool, set shell before anything touches it.
roll out pie crust
roll out pie crust
blind bake and cool crust
blind bake and cool crust

The Protein Filling

  1. Reduce the oven to 350°F.
  2. Whisk the wet ingredients. In a large mixing bowl, whisk the pumpkin puree, almond milk, and Greek yogurt together until smooth. I recommend a cordless hand mixer from KitchenAid or their regular one.
  3. Add the dry ingredients. Add the protein powder, pumpkin pie spice, and cinnamon. Whisk again until fully combined with no lumps.
  4. Add the eggs last. Crack in the whole eggs and egg white and whisk until just combined. Stop as soon as the streaks disappear. Over-mixing the eggs is the main reason pumpkin pies crack or go rubbery.
  5. Taste the filling. This step matters. Protein powders vary in sweetness, and you want to adjust now, not after it bakes. Add a little stevia or a splash of vanilla extract if it needs it.
  6. Pour into the cooled crust.
whisk wet ingredients

Bake and Chill

  1. Bake for 48 minutes. At the 25-minute mark, loosely tent the top with aluminum foil. This keeps the edges from going too dark before the center sets.
  2. Check the center. The sides should look fully cooked and set. The center should still have a slight jiggle. It will continue to firm up as it cools.
  3. Cool at room temperature for 2 to 4 hours.
  4. Chill overnight. Transfer to the fridge and let it sit at least 4 hours, overnight if possible. This is what gives you a clean slice. Without it, the filling is too soft to hold its shape when you cut it.
  5. Slice and serve. A dollop of sugar-free whipped topping or a small pinch of cinnamon on top is all it needs.
pour filling into crust
pour filling into crust
bake and chill
bake and chill

Tips for Protein Powder Pumpkin Pie Recipe

This protein powder pumpkin pie recipe is really easy to make, but here's some tips to get it right.

  • If you use homemade fresh pie crust, I recommend pre-baking it.
  • Use canned pumpkin puree since it has consistent moisture. Fresh pumpkin varies too much, and extra liquid in the filling means a longer bake and a harder set.
  • Room temperature everything for the filling. Cold yogurt and cold eggs don't blend smoothly into the puree, and you will see streaks in the baked filling.
    If eggs are out of fridge, bring to room temperature by keeping in warm water for 5 minutes.
  • Don't over-mix the batter or the pie will be too dense or crack. Stop whisking as soon as the eggs are in. More mixing after that develops the proteins in the eggs, which tightens the texture and causes cracks.
  • Cover the pie with foil after 25 minutes of baking. The filling is exposed for the whole bake if you skip it, and the top will go dry and dark before the center is ready.
  • Remove when center is still a little jiggly, but sides cooked; It will continue to cook with residual heat, and will set when cooling.
  • The Overnight Chill: I cannot stress this enough-a minimum of 4 hours, but preferably overnight in the fridge, is essential for the pie to fully set and give you beautiful, clean slices. If you are making this for Thanksgiving, bake it the day before. That is not extra work, it is better pie.

There are a lot of pumpkin dessert recipes on this site, and most of them reward a little patience at the end. This one more than most.

FAQ

Does pumpkin pie have protein?

Traditional pumpkin pie has a small amount from the eggs, usually around 5g per slice. This version builds on that with vanilla whey-casein protein powder, which brings each slice to 10.6g at 176 calories. So yes, pumpkin pie can absolutely have meaningful protein when it is built to.

How much protein is in a slice of pumpkin pie?

This protein pumpkin pie has 10.6g of protein per slice at 176 calories, based on 8 slices. A traditional pumpkin pie made with sweetened condensed milk and eggs typically has around 5g of protein per slice, depending on the recipe. The protein powder is what closes that gap.

Can I make this ahead for Thanksgiving?

Yes, and you should. Bake it the day before, cool it to room temperature, then chill it in the fridge overnight. It needs at least 4 hours to set fully, and overnight is better. This actually makes the texture cleaner and the slices easier to serve. It keeps in the fridge for up to 4 days, so baking two days ahead works fine too.

Can I use a different protein powder?

Yes! Use any sugar-free protein powder, but whey-casein is the most forgiving for baking so your texture may vary. Different types absorb liquid differently, so you might need to slightly adjust the amount of almond milk. If you use whey isolate, reduce the almond milk to about ⅓ to ½ cup since isolate absorbs liquid faster. Plant-based vanilla protein also works; add a little stevia and extra vanilla extract to balance the earthy flavor.

Why did my sugar-free pumpkin pie crack on top?

Two reasons: over-mixing the eggs, or baking too fast without the foil tent. Whisk the eggs in until they are just combined and stop there. And cover the pie loosely with foil at the 25-minute mark to slow down the top. Pulling it while the center still jiggles also helps, since over-baking tightens the filling and causes it to pull away and crack as it cools.

Can I make this crustless?

I have not tested a crustless version of this specific recipe, so I cannot give you confident numbers or a timing adjustment for it. The crust does provide structure for the filling during baking, so skipping it would likely affect the set.

STORAGE

Fridge: Airtight container or covered tightly with wrap, up to 4 days. Your homemade anabolic pumpkin pie will hold well!

To store homemade anabolic pumpkin pie, place in an airtight container and keep in the fridge up to 4 days. 

Freezer: Wrap the pie tightly in plastic wrap and slide it into a freezer-safe bag, or wrap individual slices the same way. Keeps for 2 to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge, not on the counter. Pulling it straight from the freezer to room temperature can make the filling weep a little liquid.

Protein Pumpkin Pie is soft and creamy but healthy! Made using protein powder - no sugar or condensed milk - it’s perfect to celebrate Thanksgiving party with health goals in check.

More Pumpkin Protein Dessert Ideas:

  • Single Serve Protein Pumpkin Pie
  • Pumpkin Spice Protein Pudding Pie
  • Pumpkin Protein Cheesecake Jar for One 
  • No Bake Pumpkin Protein Bars

Protein Pumpkin Pie - Soft, Creamy and So Good!

4.50 from 6 votes
Print recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time10 minutes mins
Cook Time40 minutes mins
Total Time50 minutes mins
Servings: 8 slices
Calories: 176kcal
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American, Thanksgiving
Protein pumpkin pie with 10.6g protein and 176 calories per slice. No condensed milk, no sugar in the filling, and clean slices after chilling.

Ingredients

Crust:

  • 1 Frozen Ready-to-Bake Pie Crust, Like Pillsbury

Filling:

  • 1½ cup Pumpkin Puree, not pumpkin pie filling, 360g
  • 1 cup Unsweetened Almond Milk, 240ml
  • 3 tablespoon Non-fat Plain Greek Yogurt, 42g
  • ⅔ cup + 1 Tbsp Vanilla Protein Powder, Whey-casein, 66g
  • ¾ teaspoon Pumpkin Pie Spice
  • ¼ teaspoon Cinnamon
  • 2 Eggs
  • 1 Egg White
  • Optional: Stevia Sweetener, Vanilla Exract
Are you Making This?

Please leave a ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ comment below letting me know what you think! This supports my page so I can continue to give you free recipes. Even 1 sentence is enough 🙂

Instructions

Pie Crust:

  • Preheat the oven to 450°F.
  • Roll pie crust into dish (or use pre-rolled crust) and press crust firmly on the pie dish.
  • Bake for 12-15 minutes or until edges are golden brown.
  • Remove and let cool (takes about 25 minutes).

Pie:

  • Preheat the oven to 350°F.
  • In a bowl, whisk pumpkin puree, almond milk and Greek yogurt.
  • Add protein powder, pumpkin pie spice and cinnamon; Whisk again.
  • Add eggs and egg whites and whisk until just combined.
    TASTE THE FILLING to make sure its good, and add some stevia sweetener or bit of vanilla extract if needed.
  • Pour filling into pie crust.
  • Bake 48 minutes, covering with foil after 25 minutes.
    Center should be a little bit jiggly, but sides cooked.
  • Remove from the oven and let cool 2-4 hours to room temperature.
    Tip: Place in fridge and cool overnight!

Video

Notes

  • Nutrition value is calculated using products recommended below.
  • See post for alternate ingredients, tips and storage options.
Product Recommendations:
  • Quest Nutrition Vanilla Whey-Casein Protein Powder
Nutrition:
  • Servings: 8 slices | Serving size: 1
  • Calories: 176 cal
  • Fat: 7.9g | Saturated fat: 0.4g
  • Carbohydrates: 16.9g | Fiber: 1.3g | Sugar: 2.3g
  • Protein: 10.6g
Posting your remake? Tag me on IG @hayls.kitchen!

More Recipes You'll Love

  • Healthy Halloween Snack Mix (High Protein Puppy Chow, 13g Protein!)
  • High Protein Apple Oatmeal Cookies (Soft & Low Sugar)
  • 15+ High Protein Halloween Treats: Candy Remakes, Brownies & More
  • How To Make the Best Halloween Ninja Creami Recipe

Comments

  1. Jevay Aggarwal says

    October 14, 2026 at 2:06 pm

    5 stars
    I tried this last thanksgiving and forgot to leave a comment lol. With Friendsgiving coming up and me being in charge of dessert, definitely making this again to share with all our friends 🙂

    Reply
  2. Amy says

    November 19, 2024 at 3:54 am

    5 stars
    Looks amazing and just what I was looking for beyond the typical keto crustless pumpkin pie .

    Quick question is the protein powder dual cups or scoops

    Thanks for al you do!

    Reply
    • Haylee Jane Monteiro says

      November 19, 2024 at 11:49 am

      Hi Amy!

      Thank you <3
      10/10 with you on there!

      The protein powder is 2/3 cup + 1 Tbsp or 66g, which comes to about 2 scoops + 1 Tbsp (assuming 1 scoop is 3g).

      Hope that helps, and CANNOT wait to know what you think when you try it!

      Reply
  3. Taya says

    October 13, 2024 at 5:48 pm

    5 stars
    I made it for Thanksgiving dinner today and it was a huge hit! The recipe is easy to make and the taste is delicious. I added a splash is maple syrup and a splash of vanilla extract.

    Reply
    • Haylee Jane Monteiro says

      November 03, 2024 at 2:48 pm

      omigosh YAYYY

      I'm so happy you loved it Taya! That idea with the maple syrup was really good! I bet it added a lovely richness!

      Reply
  4. Kerry says

    September 29, 2024 at 9:37 pm

    2 stars
    I tried to make the recipe exactly as it was written, expect for one teaspoon of vanilla- I included a mix of roasted pecans and chocolate chips as 1/2 cup of add ins. I found it made quite a bit more filling than would fit in one standard size frozen pie crust, so I ended up filling 2 ramekins with pie filling, creme brule style. The ramekins finished cooking a bit early, the pie took longer than 45 mins- when I first uncovered it from the foil the crust wasn't done. Cooked an additional 10-15 mins with no foil. I found the taste of the pie not very tasty- the texture was nice and light, but the taste is quite bland, and could barely taste the pumpkin. I might try blending it with vanilla Greek yogurt in a smoothie, maybe with some maple syrup. Probably won't revisit this recipe, but if ever again I would try adding sweetener, maybe stevia, and more vanilla and spices.

    Reply
    • Kerry says

      September 29, 2024 at 9:41 pm

      Opps- didn't put add ins in this one (no chocolate chips or pecans) but I can't delete the comments above- everything else still applies.

      Reply
    • Haylee Jane Monteiro says

      November 03, 2024 at 2:55 pm

      Hi Kerry, Thanks for trying out this recipe and sharing all those details.

      I'll give it another try myself for the correct portions to fit in the pie crust. I believe that some crusts might be bigger and fit more filling, but will double check.

      As for the filling and 'bland' taste - I'm wondering whether the issue is the protein powder used. Not all protein powders have the same sweetness. The one I use and linked in the post is actually quite sweet and didn't need added sweetener. Since other people have had good experiences with this recipe, I'm very inclined to believe that the issue you had might have been from a different protein powder.

      That said, I'll add a note asking readers to taste the mix and add stevia sweetener if needed.

      Reply
      • Gabriela Herrera says

        November 27, 2025 at 3:41 am

        what can I use instead of yogurt 🤔?

        Reply
        • Haylee Jane Monteiro says

          December 31, 2025 at 7:44 pm

          Hi Gabriela, you can use coconut yogurt instead. I think blended cottage cheese or sour cream would work for this too but I think you'd need to adjust the sweetness if you use the sour cream.

          Reply
  5. Brianna says

    September 21, 2024 at 6:05 am

    5 stars
    This is an awesome protein pumpkin recipe. The flavor is good and the texture is great! Whatever protein you use will really impact the flavor. I recommend a really mild vanilla and add some vanilla extract. I had a slice of this for breakfast with some homemade maple chicken breakfast Pattie’s and easily hit my 30g of protein. Thank you!!

    Reply
    • Haylee Jane Monteiro says

      November 29, 2024 at 11:28 pm

      Yayyyy! So happy you loved it too. The protein powder really is key here, and I'd recommend the extra stevia and vanilla if needed.

      Loving the idea of having pie for breakfast, haha.

      Reply
  6. Heather N says

    November 25, 2023 at 8:30 am

    5 stars
    Loved this recipe! I made 2 pies for Thanksgiving, one traditional Libby’s recipe pie and this one. My only tweets were adding more pumpkin pie spice and I added 6T monk fruit sweetener. Because I was making both at the same time I had the ability to taste test each batter as I made it. So I was trying to get as close to traditional as I could. I’ll definitely be making this again in the future. Cannot wait to try other recipes!

    Reply
    • Haylee Jane Monteiro says

      March 30, 2024 at 12:54 pm

      Hi Heather, so glad you loved the recipe! That's great that you could compare the batters side by side and the tweaks made the recipe closer to the traditional pie.

      Can't wait to see what you try next 🙂

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rating:




🍂 Fall Favorites!

  • Ultimate Healthy Apple Pie Lasagna - High Protein & Easy!
  • High protein sweet potato casserole is the best healthy Thanksgiving dessert recipe. A sweet potato souffle base with protein powder and a topping with protein pretzels - delicious and macro-friendly!
    The Best High Protein Sweet Potato Casserole for Thanksgiving!
  • Easy Pumpkin Bread with Pancake Mix and Protein Powder
  • Protein Pumpkin Pie: 11g Protein, No Sugar, No Condensed Milk

Fan Favorite Recipes

  • Rice Cake Tiramisu - High Protein, Sugar Free
  • Blueberry Protein Pancake Bread - 6-Ingredients, Quick, Heathy!
  • Healthy Protein Banana Pudding with layers of protein powder custard, sugar free vanilla waters and fresh banana. This banana cream pudding is an easy, healthy, no bake recipe without condensed milk or any added sugar.
    Protein Banana Pudding - Easy, No Sugar Added!
  • The Best Protein Carrot Cake Loaf you’ll Ever Have!

Hi, I'm Haylee!

I use my passion for baking (and my sweet tooth) to create healthy, high protein, low fat and sugar free desserts and sweet treats that are actually delicious.

Come join me in Hayl's Kitchen and let's eat high protein, sweet and guilt free!

More about me

Footer

↑ back to top

About

  • Privacy Policy
  • Nutrition Disclaimer
  • Terms & Conditions

Newsletter

  • Sign Up! for emails and updates

Contact

  • Contact
  • About
  • Media Kit

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Copyright © 2024 Hayl's Kitchen