Craving pie but want to stay on track? Browse this collection of high protein pie recipes! From Pumpkin and Apple to Chocolate and Peanut Butter, these healthy desserts are low-sugar and macro-friendly.

Let's be honest: Pie is the undisputed champion of comfort desserts. Whether it's a holiday spread or a Tuesday night treat, there is nothing quite like a creamy filling on a delicious crust. Even if its a single serve recipe you whip up in 5 minutes!
Traditional pies are usually loaded with added sugar, heavy fats, and empty calories that can derail your fitness goals in a matter of bites (get it, haha).
But what if I tell you that you can actually indulge in your favorite holiday pie while actually hitting your protein goals?
Welcome to my collection of High Protein Pie Recipes. They're not just "healthy alternatives", but desserts that taste like the real deal while fueling your body. Whether you are looking for a guilt-free dessert to bring to a potluck, or a post-workout snack, this roundup has you covered.
I promise - pick any protein pie recipe here, and it won't knock you out of that calorie deficit when you go for that 2nd (or 3rd!) slice.
P.S. Here's a link to my protein powder recommendations, baking essentials and kitchen equipment so you know where to head if you need something.
What You'll Find in This Protein Pie Recipe Roundup
I have gathered my absolute favorite recipes to cover every craving profile.
If you are a fan of fruit pies, you have to try the Ultimate Healthy Apple Pie Lasagna. For something lighter, the Easy Pear Custard Pie offers a crustless option that is super low in calories.
For the chocolate lovers, the Protein Chocolate Pie and Mini Chocolate Protein Pudding Pie are rich, decadent, and creamy without the heavy cream!
And, of course, we can't miss the classic Protein Pumpkin Pie and Protein Peanut Butter Pie 🙂
If you want something savory - this skillet pot pie with pancake crust is what you need.









Pies you can hold in your hand!



Something Unconventional









Leave a Reply