High Protein Funfetti Dip - Cake Batter Protein Dip

Name: High Protein Funfetti Dip (Cake Batter Protein Dip)
Prep time: 5 min
Total time: 5 min
Ingredients: ⅓ cup Non-fat Plain Greek Yogurt (75g); ¼ cup Low Fat Cottage Cheese (56g); ⅓ cup Vanilla Protein Powder (30g); 1½ scoop Unflavored Collagen (15g); ⅛ tsp Almond Extract; ½ Tbsp Rainbow Sprinkles (6g)

This high protein funfetti dip is a no bake cake batter protein dip made with Greek yogurt and cottage cheese, no cake mix, at 17.4g of protein for 92 calories a serving.

Jump to Recipe Jump to Video Print Recipe

I first made this back in 2023, when it ran here as a protein cake batter dip. The whole thing hinged on birthday cake protein powder - two ingredients, that powder plus yogurt. It worked, and it's still a fun trick if you own a tub of it.

That "if" was the problem. Birthday cake protein isn't exactly a pantry staple. And depending on where you live, it's hard to find at all. A reader told me she'd be making it with her fruity pebbles protein instead - a great instinct, and it proves the point. The recipe only worked if you already owned the right flavor.

So I rebuilt it around plain vanilla protein and got the cake batter flavor from almond extract instead. Almond extract is the note people actually read as birthday cake, more than vanilla is. Cottage cheese and collagen went in along the way, and the macros came out better than the original managed.

Why You'll Love This Recipe

17.4g of protein for 92 calories a serving, with 0.8g of fat (good enough for kids too)
No cake mix, no birthday cake protein powder. Plain vanilla works.
Five minutes, one blender. No baking, no chilling.
If you browse my no bake recipes, this one might be the fastest of all of them.
Tastes like actual cake batter, no raw flour anywhere near it.
Sturdy enough for pretzels, not just fruit.

Ingredients for High Protein Funfetti Dip

It's a funfetti dip with yogurt at the base!

Ingredients for no bake cake batter protein dip made with Greek yogurt and cottage cheese, no cake mix.

Non-fat Plain Greek Yogurt for tang and thickness. Plain, not vanilla - you're adding your own flavor, and vanilla yogurt makes it cloying.
- Sub: Skyr, coconut yogurt, or any thick yogurt. Runny yogurt gives you a sauce, not a dip.
Low Fat Cottage Cheese - the upgrade over the original. It blends creamy and rich in a way yogurt alone never does, and brings protein without fat.
- Sub: More Greek yogurt, or low-fat cream cheese. Both work, but you lose body.
Vanilla Protein Powder for the bulk of the protein and most of the sweetness. I use Quest Nutrition, because the whey-casein blend stays smooth instead of going chalky in a cold recipe.
- Sub: Plant based vanilla protein works, but add a pinch of stevia and a splash of vanilla extract to cut the earthy flavor. KOS or Truvani are the ones I reach for.
Unflavored Collagen to push the protein up without touching the flavor or thinning the texture. I use Vital Proteins.
- Sub: Unflavored whey or plant based protein powder. Both thicken more than collagen, so add a splash of milk if it stiffens.
Almond Extract - the whole trick. It's what your brain reads as birthday cake, and why this works without a flavored protein powder.
- TIP: Go light. Past a certain point it stops tasting like cake and starts tasting like marzipan.
Rainbow Sprinkles for the funfetti part, and the only real source of added sugar here.
- Sub: Naturally colored sprinkles if you avoid artificial dyes. They bleed faster, so fold them in right before serving.

Ingredient Swaps and Adaptations.

Dairy Free

Coconut yogurt in place of both the Greek yogurt and the cottage cheese. Use plant based protein powder, and swap the collagen for unflavored plant protein - collagen is animal-derived.

Vegan Funfetti Dip

Same as the dairy free version, plus check your sprinkles - many contain confectioner's glaze, which isn't vegan. If you want more vegan no bake options, my no bake matcha brownie protein bites are plant based and ready in 15 minutes.

Lower Carb

The dip sits at 3.7g of carbs a serving, and the sprinkles are the only thing adding sugar. Leave them off or use a sugar free sprinkle to bring it lower.

How to Make Cake Batter Protein Dip Without Cake Mix

There's no cooking here at all, which means it's one of those quick desserts you can whip up when you want curb your sweet tooth.

Blend the base: Add the cottage cheese, Greek yogurt, vanilla protein powder, collagen and almond extract into a large bowl and combine with an immersion blender (or use a blender or food processor) until completely smooth like a frosting. Cottage cheese curds don't break down by hand, so a whisk won't get there. Scrape the sides at least once.
After the cottage cheese note, you could add: "I blend it the same way for my protein tiramisu croissant - it's the move that makes cottage cheese go silky instead of lumpy.

Blend — Combine ingredients except sprinkles

Taste before you commit: Protein powders range wildly in sweetness, so taste now and add stevia or another sugar-free sweetener if needed. This is also the moment for a drop more almond extract, though err toward less.
Fold in the sprinkles: Transfer the dip to a bowl first, then fold the sprinkles in by hand. Blended, the coating dissolves and the whole thing turns murky grey.
Serve or chill: Ready immediately, but 30 minutes in the fridge firms it up and lets the almond extract settle into the dairy.

If you want something similar that's scoopable with crackers at a party, my protein cheesecake dip is worth bookmarking.

Tips for the Best Healthy Funfetti Dip

Blend longer than feels necessary. Give it another 20 seconds when you think it's done. Whether the cottage cheese fully broke down is the whole difference.
I use the same rule for my protein peanut butter pie to make sure the filling is silky smooth.
Room temperature dairy blends smoother. Straight from the fridge, cottage cheese takes longer to go silky.
Measure the almond extract. A free pour from the bottle is how you end up with marzipan instead of cake batter.
Sprinkles last, every time. The step people skip, and the one that decides how it looks.
Thin it with milk, not water. A splash loosens it without washing out the flavor.

What to Serve With It

Sturdy enough to hold a pretzel, which the original wasn't.

Pretzels, for the salt against the sweet
Graham crackers or animal crackers, closest to the original protein dunkaroo dip
Strawberries and apple slices
Rice cakes
Cookies or other dippers
A spoon, which is how it usually goes as a snack

This high protein funfetti dip is perfect as a dunkaroo dip

FAQ

The questions I get most on this one.

How much protein is in this funfetti dip?

Each ¼ cup serving has 17.4g of protein and 92 calories, with 0.8g of fat and 3g of sugar. That's 18.9g of protein per 100 calories, a better ratio than the original two-ingredient version managed.

Can you make funfetti dip without cake mix?

Yes, and this healthy cake batter dip never uses any. Boxed cake mix in a dip is mostly raw flour and sugar - a food safety issue as well as where the calories come from. Here the flavor comes from almond extract and vanilla protein powder instead.

Can I make this without collagen peptides?

Yes. Swap it 1:1 with unflavored whey or unflavored plant-based protein powder. Both thicken the dip more than collagen does, so add a small splash of milk if it comes out too stiff.

Why do I have to fold the sprinkles in by hand instead of blending them?

The blender breaks down the candy coating on the sprinkles, which bleeds color into the dip and turns it grey. Fold them in at the very end, and if you're using naturally colored sprinkles, add them right before serving since those bleed even faster.

My dip came out lumpy.

What went wrong? The cottage cheese curds didn't fully break down. A whisk won't get there, so you need a blender or small food processor, and it needs to run longer than feels necessary. Scrape the sides at least once mid-blend, and if your dairy came straight from the fridge, let it sit at room temp for a few minutes first.

What can I use instead of almond extract if I have an allergy?

Use vanilla extract instead, about ½ tsp. It won't hit the same birthday cake note that almond extract gives you, but a drop of butter extract alongside vanilla gets you closer to that baked-batter flavor

Storage

This birthday cake batter protein dip keeps better than most no bake recipes.

Fridge: Airtight container, up to 4 days. It thickens as it sits; stir in a splash of milk to loosen it.

Freezer: Up to 2 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge, then stir well - it separates slightly.x

Variations

White Chocolate chip: Fold sugar free white chocolate chips in with the sprinkles. I'd use Lily's white chocolate chips here.
Lemon: Swap the almond extract for lemon zest and a little juice for a lemon cake version.
Strawberry: Blend freeze-dried strawberries into the base for color and flavor without added liquid.

More Easy High Protein Dip and Spread Recipes